Memoranda for Submission to the Chief Ministers of the Two Telugu States.

Articles

How Long Will India’s Democracy Endure

 Dt:18/11/24

How Long Will India’s Democracy Endure

 

 Dr T.H.Chowdary*

 

 

1. Celebratory Facts:

 

Let us recall some celebratory superlative facts about Bharat that was India.

·         Ours is the most populous country

·         The largest democracy with adult franchise  including women even to start with in the first general elections to  the Lok Sabha

·         We made the  largest number  (103) of  amendments to our Constitution ( USA amended its Constitution 27 times since it was ratified  in 1787; the last amendment was on 2nd November 1949)

·         We have the largest  number of voters at about 900 million

·         We graduate 1.5 mln engineers the largest number in the  world every year

·         We have the largest number of  unemployed post-matriculates

·         We feed the largest number ( over 800 mln) of people receiving ten free rationed items of food grains

·         We have the largest number of political parties – 6 national, 58 state and  2763 unrecognized ones.

·         We are the 5th  largest economy in world  with  an  annual  GDP of  $ 3.7 trln. Our Per Capita GDP is  about one fifth that of China and about 124th of the USA.

·         All these  superlatives affect the quality of our democracy.

 

 

 

1.2 Only once between June 1975 and  March 1977 was the Constitution assaulted by the  lady Prime Minister  Indira (Priyadarshini Nehru) Gandhi. Her  captive party  encouraged  and assisted by one Communist party, declared national emergency ; the  CPI prolonged the term of the  Lok Sabha , did away with some fundamental rights in the  Constitution  locked up most of the opposition  leaders and made  her election unchallengeable  in any court of law including the  Supreme Court of  India.  But since the end of  such “emergency rule” , there are free and  fair elections at constitutionally mandated  to the intervals Union Parliament and  all State Legislative Assemblies.

 

2. Threats to our Democracy  and Integrity:

 

2.1 The five South Indian States  ( AP, Karnataka, Kerala , Tamilnadu and  Telangana) together have  16.3% of the area of Bharat and 23%  of the population with a density of   492 per sq. kmts compared to  the rest of India’s  356 per sq.kmts with 129 MPs in the Lok Sabha out of 543 ; the South MPs are  23.8% .

 

Five Southern States  - AP, Karnataka, Kerala, Tamilnadu and Telangana

 

Area

Population

MPs in Lok Sabha

Population Density

16.3%

23%

23.8%

South

Rest of India

 

 

 

492

356

 

Decadal Population Growth (2001-2011)

 

AP ( undivided)

Karnataka

Kerala*

Tamil Nadu

11.1%

15.67%

4.86%

15.6%

* Far below north and whole of India

 

2.2 The South’s population growth is significantly less that of the rest  of  India,  especially compared to  the north India states.  There is  an apprehension that  census  2025  will show further increase in  disparity  in the populations of  north India ( especially  Hindi speaking belt and South India and therefore the number  of seats in Lok Sabha for the  southern states especially Kerala, will go down as percentage of the total  Lok Sabha states.  The  share of the  South Indian states in  the  distributable  taxes  will further go down  if the 2025 census is taken as the basis. Instead   of rewarding  the states which are  controlling their population  growth they are getting penalized.  The resentment in south will go up  and the demand  for “federalism” will increase. The Chief Ministers of  AP & Tamilnadu are,  in disgust calling upon their people to have  more  children.   That will be a disaster both for the  South and  even for the whole of  India  . Therefore  a new proportion  for the distributable revenues collected by the  Union government will have to be found so that the states that control their population growth will get more  and those are   simply increasing their population will get less. The  population density in Bihar  is 1,195 per sq. kmt,  the highest in India and therefore it is the  poorest state  with  less than Rs. 65,000 per capita income; whereas the all India  average is about  Rs. 1,75,000 and that of  Telangana  is  over Rs. 300,000 the highest  in India.

 

2.3  Bharat as the  5th Largest Economy – Facts and Fiction:

 

Our Prime Minister often talks of Vikasit Bharat ( developed India) says that ours is the fifth largest economy in the world and would  soon become the third largest after the USA and China.  Look at the  fact sin the  table below.

 

Country

USA

China

Germany

Japan

India

 

GDP ($ Trln)

 27

17.7

4.4

4.2

3.7

Pop (mln)

333

1,444

81

127

1,341

Per Capita GDP ($)

81,818

12,258

54,321

33,071

2,643

 

The economy is large but per capita at $ 2,643 ( about Rs. 2,16,000) it is a little less than one fifth of China, our unfriendly neighbour.  Can this be comforting to a Vikasit status aspiring Bharat ?  

 

3. Freebies – Competitive : Guarantees Instead of  Promises :

 

3.1 Political parties, especially the regional ones  are making reckless promises of welfare payout.  There are  elections  almost round the year  in some state or the other. The national parties BJP and the  Congress are competing with the regional parties.  To beat one another  more  and more  freebies  are being  promised. Now they have become so many and so much that instead  of  promises unfilled in the past  they are giving  guarantees ! The all -India  parties are being forced to join this race of  giving freebies. In AP   one regional party, YSRCP during the period 2019-24  was transferring  Rs. 48,000  per year for 80% of the families in the  state !  It was borrowing  money and distributing it. It increased the  state- owned corporations to over 50. The state was taking loans  in the name of those  companies   and distributing the   borrowed money towards  bank guarantee ! The state pledged the next twenty years revenue it may get from excise duty on wine !  The regional parties are agitating for more funds from the  Union Government for every “give-away social welfare”  scheme.  They assert  their Right to Spend and the Union Government’s  Duty to Fund.  One party  candidate in Maharashtra has promised to find and fund a spouse  for marriage of the unmarried in need !  State-owned  corporations for marriages, Surrogacy and  Fertility ( all free)  are being contemplated  to dispense further social welfare from womb to tomb/ grave.   

 

3.2 Since there are  elections  at  different intervals in some state or the other almost every year, parties are competing to give  more and  more freebies, many of them out of borrowed money. The philosophy is”  “our (states)  right to spend : your ( Union government) duty to fund”. This is getting accentuated by the  phrase double engine growth. For eg: BJP -led government   at the center  and the BJP government in the state will ensure  double engine  growth !  Naturally the   regional parties are  against  “one nation one election”.  The rational for  one  nation one election ( from Zilla Parishad State  legislature and the  Lok Sabha )  is to avoid  the ever growing  election  expenses  to the   government as well as to the political parties.   Round the year  election  in some state or other is making  political parties  to promise, rather guarantee more freebies  in  the state having the elections  next.

 

4. Buying Votes with Government Money:

 

4.1  Now the freebies  in some states are given   in the personal name of the Chief Minister . This system started in AP  ruled by the Telugu Desam Party led by Sri Chandra Babu Naidu during 2014-19. Some of  the freebies  were called Chandranna  Kanukalu, ( gifts) and Chandranna Pasupu Kumkamulu (auspicious gifts for  ladies in the  self- help groups).  The succeeding government  by the  YSRCP Chief Minister named every gift scheme either after  himself or his father.  There were about 40 such   schemes.  This is rank corruption -misuse of state money for self-aggrandizement and electoral victory.

 

4.2  The state’s money  is gifted in another way.  For eg:   in  AP there are   59 state- owned corporations.  When there are  government departments with Secretaries , Special  Secretaries, Joint Secretaries  and Additional Secretaries etc.,  for all the  matters  dealt with by the state-owned corporations, what is the necessity  for these corporations ?  The Chairmen  of these corporations  are  nominated  by the Chief Minister . None of them has qualification to run any business or industry. They are simply  ruling party MLAs who could not be   made  ministers or financiers or vote-supplies for  the ruling party  who cannot be rewarded as   either  MLAs  or ministers. Through the freebies  being  distributed and rewarding   some  party people  by appointing / nominating them as Chairmen, the State’s funds are squandered to promote ruling party interests. These nominated chairmen are  provided with gun-men for protection  and impressive offices, secretaries, PAs, PSs, liveried peons, costly cars, and such paraphernalia, besides huge salaries .   

 

 

5. Caste-based Power and Welfare:     The Indo-Italian -led Congress ( of Mother-Son-Daughter) promises “ jitne aabadee- utanee power”  and so  demands caste census, so it can distribute power, welfare, employment etc., among  castes in proportion to their  numbers.  The last census-enumerating caste was in 1931.  The Indian National Congress   under the leadership of the true Gandhi, the Mahatma agitated  and succeeded in forcing the  imperial  British government of India  to stop caste enumeration in the  census 1941 and so in no subsequent census  of free India there  caste  enumeration. But now we have a different  Congress which  swears  by caste-based distribution of  power , and welfare in the name of just democracy, where caste and  not the   individual who merits power and welfare. Dr Ambedkar’s life-long struggle for the  annihilation  of caste to bring about fraternity among people has been in vain and caste gets an invigorated  and decisive new relevance in the  sharing of power and prosperity !

 

 

6. Election Expenses:

 

6.1 The amount of money that the candidates have to spend   in the election to the  state assembly and to the Lok Sabha  have been going up and  up  by leaps and bounds .The candidates  and their  parties are  distributing money  to the  voters.  The voter  is getting money  from the  two  principal  parties contesting for  victory.  Since   voters  still have some  senses of  morality.  If there are   four votes in a household, each voter is receiving  money  from  both the parties  and half  of them  are voting for one party and   the other half for rival  party !

 

6.2  Hundreds of crores of rupees are  transported in different ways for distribution among   voters are getting seized by the police.  Such amounts are increasing year after year. Elections at different  times for the state assembly and Lok Sabha are  involving more and  more money  being acquired by illegal means and  stashed in  cash for distribution among  voters. This note for  vote  culture  is becoming  more and more costly and notorious. The  amount of  money that the  voter  is expecting  and being  met with by the rival candidates is increasing.   Democracy thus  is increasingly becoming hostage to cash distribution . The cash is getting accumulated  by avoiding taxes.  

 

6.3 Democracy is  getting vitiated by injection  of  cash and material gifts to voters and the  need to  generate  black money for buying the votes. One nation, one election expected among other benefits, less cost to government and  candidates   needs many amendments to the   Constitution.  Whether those amendments can be  successfully made or not is in doubt.  

 

7. Threat to Integrity of the  Nation and State:

 

7.1  While these are general afflictions to democracy in India,   the integrity of  the country itself  is under peril.  Muslims by the very theology of Islam cannot be part of a non-Muslim nation.  They are part of transnational  millat . That Muslims  are  a different nation by dint of their  religion  was successfully agitated  leading to the  partition of India and the  creation of the Islamic state of  Pakistan  which in 1971 broke  into two  on the  basis of difference in languages in  the two parts of  Pakistan. Muslim countries  may divide into different states but  Muslims in a non-Muslim state want  disintegration of the  combined state for   creation of an  exclusively   Muslim state as  happened in India in 1947. When the Ottoman   Turkish empire   was dismantled  at the end of the  First World War (1914-‘19),   there was an exchange of Muslim & Christian populations under the  auspices of the   League  of  Nations  between Turkey,  the Muslim state and  Bulgaria  and Greece which are   mainly Christian .

 

7.2  In India,  for a few years  before  partition of the  country the  Muslim League  stridently demanded  exchange of minority populations ; that is, all  Muslims  from Hindustan (that is, India) to go to  Pakistan  to be created and the  non-Muslims like Hindus and   Sikhs and Buddhists from Pakistan  to be  sent  to Hindustan. Since Mahatma Gandhi and the Congress said  they accept partition but  they don’t accept the  two- nation theory. As a  corollary  exchange of   population; Muslims can stay in India even if Hindus and Sikhs are  expelled from Pakistan. The Muslim League did not press for exchange  of minority population. Therefore most  Muslims in what is  now India  who  agitated for   division  and creation  of  the Islamic state of  Pakistan did not go to  Pakistan.  A few of them  from west UP  and some parts of  Bihar   only  went to  Pakistan. Nearly the  17%  Hindu -Sikh  population of   west Pakistan  was reduced to less than 2% . In retaliation some  Muslims  in east Punjab and Haryana were forced out (not by government)  by militant  majorities. In east Pakistan  which  now is  Bangladesh  the expulsion of   Hindus  has been  at intervals. Thus the once 33% Hindu Buddhist  minorities have by now squeezed out  to about 6% and still going down. The   32 year long  communist government  and the Trinamool government that followed  in  West Bengal   allowed  illegal infiltration of millions   of Muslims from east Pakistan  .

 

7.3 The  result is  17%  Muslim  population of  West Bengal soon  after partition has,  become 35% and is increasing.  Infiltration  has  spread upto Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh and even Orissa. The Bangla Muslims and  Bangla speaking Rohingya  Muslims are settling among their  co-religionist Indian families, marrying  into them and somehow registering  as Indians for  ration cards and voter list. The Rohingyas, Bengali speaking Muslims, expelled from Myanmar are  getting settled in  even far off  Kerala  and in J&K; but   not in the Muslim majority Kashmir valley but in  Hindu majority Jammu city and environs. This is with the  deliberate intent of  changing the demography of   Jammu where they are settling.

 

7.4 Another menace to Indian democracy is the persisting  divisiveness     and  its encouragement by vote-seeking non-BJP parties  -  the  Indo- Italian family-  led Congress and  the  regional parties.  That the  Indo-Italian family -led Congress has been  specially promoting   Muslims interests in order to get their votes is   evident from the following  Congress -led UPA government   appointed Sachar Committee. It  identified over  80  districts  spread all over India  as having considerable  Muslim  population.  It is in  pursuit of  special Muslim First  programs, that   the purportedly  “secular  UPA government  created  the  National Waqf  Development Corporation  with a capital of  Rs .375 cr then raised to Rs. 875 cr for the development of   waqfs  . The income of this corporation is solely and fully for the promotion and welfare  of   only Muslims with government money . The Congress also created  the National Minority Commission at Union Level. In states where Hindus are  a minority as in J&K, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Nagaland (and very soon Kerala) there are no minority commissions.   Thus, the interests   of Muslims are being promoted  specially  by the non-BJP  parties, mainly Congress and the regional parties.  India is progressively ceasing to be a secular state.  It is becoming an “ansar*” state.  ( *Ansars were those Madina people who helped Prophet Mohammad’s conquests and converted to Islam) 

 
 

 

 

Moslems may  expect no more tolerance than what they show to others

 

- Nobel  Laureate Sir Vidyadhar S. Naipaul

 

 

7.5  That  Muslim majority  areas all over India  are required and for what purposes had been  clearly spelt out by the  Hyderabad origin Muslim intellectual,  Dr. Omar Khalidi ( a post graduate of Harvard  University and Ph.D  from University of Wales)  in the   Jamat-e-Islami ‘s weekly, “Radiance” : “ we need Muslim districts for three reasons. First , concentrated areas provide security; second, to provide an environment that is conducive to our cultural independence; third, to provide a political base through which our people can be elected ……at present…our numbers don’t’ add up to elect adequate  legislators. Hyderabad & Rangareddy in Andhra and Gulbarga (Karnataka) and certain Talukas  could be  merged to create Deccan province ( with Muslim majority) similarly  in Bihar, Bengal & UP.. where Muslims  can be in majority…”.

 

7.6 Further one  Prof. Samar Abbas, another  Muslim intellectual wrote in the leftist Economic Political Weekly of December 2000 that India should be   divided further  to provide a Muslim state, Mughalistan comprising of   the Western  districts of Assam northern districts  of  West Bengal, Bihar  and UP  and Punjab to  form a continuous  belt   adjoining Pakistan  on the  West and Bangladesh  on the  East.   This reminds  us of Md Ali Jinnah wanting  a corridor  across  Northern  India  to link up  West  and East  Pakistan (Bangladesh). It is  possible that  in their   bid to  get  Muslim block votes,  regional parties as well as  the Indo-Italian family-led Congress  and   congenitally anti-Hindu communist parties  may  if and when  and  instates elected create  the 80 (Muslim First claim on development (not SCs or STs or MBCs) districts identified by Sachar Committee  into Muslim majority districts  like Malappuram in Kerala  ( a CPI/CPM creation), Mewat out of Gurgaon in Haryana and Malerkotla  in Punjab (both created by Congress). 

 

 

7.7 The prospect is that these Muslim-majority districts specially carved and developed by government funds  ( including those from the National Waqf Development Corporation) will  first form  a society, then an Association and  then a Federation  of them ; finally constitute themselves into an independent Islamisthan  as an enclave  in India much like Lesotho in South Africa.  The Nawab of Bhopal as Chairman of the  Chamber of (Indian) Princes ( Rajas, Maharajas & Nawabs) tried to beguile  and lead  India’s Princes / Nawabs to constitute themselves into a third state, Pricesthan besides Pakistan and Hindustan / India, when Britain  renounces its  paramountcy over princes and gives independence to India.  This move was thwarted by Mountbatten, the Vice-Roy at Sardar Patel’s commanding advice in June 1947.  It was to thwart the   Nizam of Hyderabad from becoming an independent  sovereign king of Hyderabad state that Sardar Patel, much against the  opposition of Nehru, sent the Indian army in September 1948  into Hyderabad and  liberated and integrated  it with the rest of Bharat.  Will enfeebled, democratic India disintegrate like post – Aurangzeb - ruled India ?  This fear was  expressed by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar ( Annex#2) in his speech on 26 Nov 1949 in the  concluding session of the  Constituent Assembly.  Dr Rajendra Prasad (Annex#3)  expressed the fear that the  Constitution cannot save India  if politicians don’t have character. 

 

7.8 Muslim voters are demanding  Haj Houses,  enhancement of Haj subsidies, funding madrasas,, paying  salaries to Imams and muezzins, funding the National Waqf Development Corporation  national state minority commission even while  we have  the National Human (including Muslims) Rights Commission. 

 

8. Secularism Abused:  The secularism the noble idea that is inscribed into our Constitution is  undermined by  implementing Articles - 25 to 30  in favour  of the Muslim   and Christian minorities whose religions direct their followers to convert all the  world’s population to their own religion.  Therefore  the Indian democracy  and the state  and  Hindus in particular are  terribly menaced   by  deterioration  in the  purpose and quality of  politics . While  in the west through a series of measures  and experiences, politics has become  a profession  governed  by professional   systematized ethics ,  in India politics is morphing into commerce  and  contest for the  power market . It is  getting more and more corrupted. It is  well to recall what  Bhagwan Krishna had  messaged in the  Bhagawad Gita  :

 

yadyadacharati ?hre?h?has tattadevetaro jana?

sa yatpram??a? kurute lokastadanuvartate

-B.G 3.21

 

Meaning: As the leaders act, so the people; the standard the leaders  set, the people follow.

 

9. Parivarvad:   The deterioration in the  quality of India’s  democracy is entirely due to the degradation of many  political leaders . What has come to be known as parivarvad   has its source from Motilal Nehru and his   progeny  - Jawaharlal , Indira and Rajiv and his Indo -Italian  children.  Following their example  in many states  the  powerful and effective leadership  and therefore  power is in the hands of the Parivar’s  head.  Powerful and  the wealthy politicians  are having their  children succeed them in the  realm of  politics and party governments.

 

10. Education: 

 

10.1 At the time of Independence , literacy in India was under 20% . So  it was in South Korea, China, Malaysia.  All of them  who became self-governing have attained literacy levels  above 95% within forty/ fifty years .  77 years after independence , literacy in India is 74.4%

 

S.Korea

Sri Lanka

Myanmar

Malaysia

98

92.3

89

95

China

Indonesia

Surinam

Fiji

96.8

96

94.4

99.1

Mauritius

Guyana

Trinidad

Pakistan

91.3

88.5

99

58

 Bangladesh

 

 

 

74.6

 

 

 

 

10.2 All our neighbours except Pakistan have higher literacy than India, though they got  independence later than us.  The countries where Indians had gone as “coolies” in the 19th century  are  now majorities and ruling because of higher education.  Sir Vidyadhar S.Naipaul of  Trinidad is a Nobel Laureate.  Several  Indians settled  abroad got Nobel prize. Few Indians in India  are Nobel  laureates is reason we have neglected education .  

 
 

 

 

History will record that the greatest mistake of the Indian republic in the first 50 years  (77 now) of its existence was to make less investment in human resources- education, family planning, nutrition and public health- than in brick and motor dams and factories”. - Sri Nani Palkhiwala

 

Education makes a people easy to lead but difficult to drive; easy to govern, but difficult to enslave  - Henry Peter Brougham

 

“…no improvement is possible with unimproved people, and advance is certain when people are liberated and educated.  It would be wrong to dismiss the importance of roads, railroads, power plants, mills and the other familiar furniture of economic development…”    - John Kenneth Galbraith

 

 

 

10.3 Aspiration and education can make even those of low birth and poverty affluent, powerful and  distinguished. This  is proved by poor, even destitute Indians, “coolies” who went as “indenture”  labourers in sugar plantations of the  British, Dutch and  French colonies rising to  political power and Nobel laureates .    Mauritius, Surinam, Fiji, Guyana, Trinidad and  Tobago are  countries where former  Indian “Coolies’ have risen to political power and Prime Ministers . Sir Vidyadhar Naipaul of  Trinidad & Tobago is a Nobel Laureate . Indian scientists, engineers and  business graduates are  in  the ranks of Nobel Laureates and  chiefs of USA’s global corporations. Indian democracy as noted by N A  Palkhiwala has not yet been able to give  quality education to the young as even civil war ravaged South Korea has done.  China competes, even excels USA in regard to the  frontier science and  technology  of artificial intelligence, AI . Many of our politicians are  more  interested in competitively promising / guaranteed freebies, than in delivering quality education to all.  In fact, education  from pre-school / LKG to PG is getting privatised  even as banks, industries and  trade and  insurance were nationalised .

 

 

11. Judiciary

 

11.1 If a telegraphic address is to be given to our judicial courts, the most apt one would be “ ADJOURNMENT”.  The adjournments given most liberally are so  vexatious and  make justice so costly and  delayed that in the words of one  of our greatest lawyers, the  late N A Palkhiwala,  “A law suite once started in India is the nearest thing to eternal life ever seen on this earth….” 

 

11.2 The Justices of the  Supreme Court want  to select and decide themselves as to who should be the  Justices. The utmost concession they give to the Executive ( the PM, President or  Parliament) is that instead of the  Chief Justice alone, a collegium of senior most judges will make the selection and  it has to be accepted by the President.  This has no parallel in the world ! 

 

11.3 The Supreme Court  directed the State High  Courts  to constitute special C.B.I Courts to expeditiously try MLAs, MPs and ministers charged with corruption . That  this is unheeded but is  just a famous supreme order is evident from a former MP who was in jail for eighteen months on serious charges of corruption  established by the  CBI has been on bail since over twelve years, during which he became the  Chief Minister for fiver years, lost the  latest election  for his party and is an MLA now.  He managed not to appear even once in the   Special CBI court; this court’s judges were transferred seven times and the  case against him is as it was twelve years ago without  trial !  His daughters who are  students have become  multi  millionaires!

 
 

 

 

Words have sometimes to be violent because  they represent assault of thought on the unthinking.    - Lord Maynard Keynes

 

 

 

11.4 A retired Chief Justice of the Supreme Court when asked  whether  there is corruption in the  Supreme Court judges answered: “ They are from our society: If MLAs, MPs, ministers could be corrupt why not judges?”  A  Supreme Court judge facing impeachment resigned and another’s  impeached was unsuccessful.

 

12. The Evangelist Fraud

 

12.1 Our Constitution confers reservations in  government jobs and educational institutions ; state legislatures, parliament and  such elected bodies . Persons among Schedule Castes (SCs) and  Schedule Tribes (STs) are getting  converted to Christianity in several dubious ways.  The  converted seem to be instructed to hide the fact of conversion and simply write SC/ ST in all applications.  Thus, the converts are  fraudulently depriving  the real Hindu SCs and STs from the benefits of reservation.  Many MPs, MLAs, IAS, IPS, IFS etc.,  officers seem to be impostor  SCs.

 

12.2 According to the  census, the Christian population in  undivided AP  has been  declining but the churches are  proliferating in the  territory.   The proof of the fraud is revealed in my letter of Feb 2019 to a retired “SC” IAS officer ( Annex#1). The officer did not reply.

 

13. Abuse of Fundamental Rights: Democratic India’s greatest failure is not eliminating  the  insurrection, the civil war being waged since the late 1970s by the Maoist Communist Party  ( one of about half a dozen communist parties in India) with its Peoples’ War Guerrilla  (PWG)  battalions.  This is the   longest civil war in history.  If  India  cannot defeat the Maoist  PWG, and bring normalcy  in the areas the PWG is operating, can we be confident to win wars against  our  implacable enemies on our western and northern borders?  The PWG cannot be waging war without supply of  money  and weapons and  promotion of indecision in government and  wrong appraised among some political  parties.  This is what “urban Naxalites”  are doing.  They are in fact the above-ground units of the  PWG.  They are invoking fundamental rights & human rights.   These are for normal citizens;  not for armies and  parties  that wage war against the  state and  summarily execute whom they suspect as “informers” and “collaborators”.  Indian democracy will be failing the people if it does not  defeat and eliminate  the  Maoist PWG   war-waging communist parties   .

 

14. National Integration:

 

14.1 The National Integration Council (NIC) was established in 1961 by Sri Jawaharlal Nehru to address issues like communalism, casteism and regionalism and promotion of harmony.  It consists of chief Ministers, eminent public men and intellectuals.  It is neither a constitutional nor a statutory body.  It is to meet every six months, chaired by the   Prime Minister.    It first met in June 1962. The 16th and the last meeting was on 16 Sept 2013.  Since then it is non-functional.  And for good reasons Muslims by the theology  of Islam cannot sincerely agree to be integrated with non-Muslims .   In India they rioted and voted for division  of the country and creation of the Islamic state of  Pakistan. Abetted by vote-mongering “secular” parties, they are  demanding reservations for them, creation of Muslim-majority districts, funds for Haj pilgrimage and  Islamic schools (Madrasas) .

 

14.2 There are thousands of  mosques constructed on destroyed temples (sometimes called Hindu Masjids)  like those in Ayodhya, Varanasi, Mathura, Dhar, Rajamahendravaram etc.  Hindus claim these  sites for reconstruction of destroyed temples .  Muslims don’t agree . The strife is intensifying .  To reduce strife, the  first step is to establish by law a “ Truth and  Reconciliation Commission” as in South Africa and  Peru.  The second step is to task the  Archaeological  Survey  of  India to conduct scientific tests as in Ayodhya in important disputed Hindu Masjids ( i.e mosques on destroyed temple sites) and  resolve the disputes.

 

14.3 Yet another Hindu-Muslim divide unresolved is “waqf” properties.  The Muslim Waqf Boards go on claiming properties of people, temple even High Courts as waqfs.  At this rate they may claim the entire territory ruled by Aurangzeb  as Waqfs.  Actually,  waqf are  Islamic Imperialisms remains .  Just as princely states , privy purses, Zamindaris were all abolished, just as the former French and Portuguese territories in India  were reintegrated with the rest of India;  Waqfs, the spoils of conquest  may be  taken over by the  state.  Travancore State dedicated to Hindu God  Padmanabha by the  ruler  Marthanda Varma  in 1750 was taken over and merged with the  rest of India.  If this Waqf  issue is not solved, India’s democracy will continue to be vitiated by Hindu-Muslim strife.

 

15. Hope and Endeavour:

 

15.1 Inspite of  the deficiencies and  distortions   and corruptions in the operation of our democracy  we can still   hope and endeavour build  a prosperous,  powerful,   intellectual and ethical   nation to be  a Viswa Guru  once again . Millions  among our young  are  becoming   slowly but steadily aware of the glorious past   -   that till 1707 ( Aurangzeb’s’ death)  Bharat  was the  largest rich nation with   China as our equal,  both  with about 25%  of the  world’s trade. It was so even during  the long period of  Islamist imperial rule in much of  Bharat.  The decline and fall began with  most exploitative, imperialist British rule bent upon  rooting out  our heritage wealth that we became a weak nation.   The foreign Islamist rule  and   the Marxist communist  visceral enmity to  Hinduism had dulled our   perceptive power . Our  education and thinking  got colonized  by the  imperial  British rule. Increasing  number of our intellectual class are doing away with  Marxist - communist, Islamist  anti- sanatan dharma positions  and getting aware of all human -embracing philosophy of Sanatan Dharma and are  getting  determined to make Bharat  a great  super power for Bahujana Hitaya, Bahujana Sukhaya (for the  good of all people , for the comfort of all people).  May the  following  few Maha Vakyas guide us  so that  as Swami Vivekananda exhorted us  : “arise, awake and stop not till the  goal is reached “ .

 

 
 

 

 

"If you will not fight for the right when you can easily win without bloodshed; if you will not fight when your victory will be sure and not too costly; you may come to the moment when you will have to fight with all the odds against you and only a small chance of survival. There may even be a worse case: you may have to fight when there is no hope of victory, because it is better to perish than to live as slaves."    -Winston Churchill

 

 

 

 

15.2  The sage Aurobindo envisioned that man will become superman  as  evolution  does not  stop with  Homo-sapiens   that is, human beings.  Artificial Intelligence (AI) now being developed and adopted can make us superman hopefully with saatvik qualities .

 

16. Dharmic Aspirations:

 

Whether the deterioration in politics and the corruptions  are  temporary phenomenon or not  will have to be  decided by the   vast majority which  Hindus are  by themselves getting informed and inspired  by dharma, righteousness  which in Bharat has  the  following  noble messages to mankind  informing life and   conduct of people.

 

·         Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam..

·         Ekam sat, viprah bahudhaa vadanti

·         Krinvato viswamaaryam

 

 

·         o? sarve bhavantu sukhina?

sarve santu nir?may??

sarve bhadr??i pa?yantu m? ka?ciddu? khabh?gbhaveta?

o? ??nti? ??nti? ??nti??

 

·         o? saha n?vavatu .

saha nau bhunaktu .

saha v?rya? karav?vahai .

tejasvi n?vadh?tamastu m? vidvi??vahai .

o? ??nti? ??nti? ??nti? ..

 

 

17. I will end this  long article by  rephrasing Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore’s  prayer:

 

Where the Hindu is  without fear  

 

Where the Hindu is  “Without Fear”

Where true  history is told and every Hindu  holds his head high

Where Bharat is not broken into  Muslim and Christian districts

Where words come  out from the depth of  truth

Where reason and inquiry  are not  silenced by terror of fanatics 

Where treason and guilt  lead to  insecurity in those who harbour them

Into the heaven of freedom, honest endeavour  and divine  grace

My Father ! let my country awake   and march

(With apologies to Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore )

(5,377 words)

END